Mafia Mystery Fan Gifts

Searching for the ideal gift for someone obsessed with mafia mysteries? Explore our collection of clever, themed items that resonate with fans of crime-solving, secret societies, and suspenseful plots, perfect for sparking their curiosity and adding a touch of mystery to their everyday life.

All Products Prints T-Shirts Mugs Pillows

"Angelo tells us you haven't been laughing."

"Angelo tells us you haven't been laughing." mockup

"Angelo tells us you haven't been laughing."

from $19.00

"Housekeeping?!"

from $19.00

He looks so natural lying there... mockup

He looks so natural lying there...

from $19.00

"Play 'Misty' for me."

from $19.00

"Then leave the horses head in the Futon." Middle-class mafia

"Then leave the horses head in the Futon." Middle-class mafia mockup

"Then leave the horses head in the Futon." Middle-class mafia

from $19.00

Tree Mobsters. 'I didn't hear anything. Did you hear anything?' 'I didn't hear anything.'

Tree Mobsters. 'I didn't hear anything. Did you hear anything?' 'I didn't hear anything.' mockup

Tree Mobsters. 'I didn't hear anything. Did you hear anything?' 'I didn't hear anything.'

from $19.00

'And in local news: Someone is hiding behind the drapes.'

'And in local news: Someone is hiding behind the drapes.' mockup

'And in local news: Someone is hiding behind the drapes.'

from $19.00

Dog detectives

from $19.00

"I did, boss, I swear, I buried him myself."

"I did, boss, I swear, I buried him myself." mockup

"I did, boss, I swear, I buried him myself."

from $19.00

"Undiagnosed serial killer"

from $19.00

Cosa Nostradamus: "Listen, you mook. I predict if you don't pay the vig to the Don by tonight you'll be at the bottom of the Hudson by morning."

Cosa Nostradamus: "Listen, you mook. I predict if you don't pay the vig to the Don by tonight you'll be at the bottom of the Hudson by morning." mockup

Cosa Nostradamus: "Listen, you mook. I predict if you don't pay the vig to the Don by tonight you'll be at the bottom of the Hudson by morning."

from $19.00

Nancy Drew Mysteries - The Later Years mockup

Nancy Drew Mysteries - The Later Years

from $19.00

Gangsta wrap.

from $19.00

'Lewis and Cabrini.'

from $19.00

"Another clear case of COVID19."

from $19.00

'He's been shot!'

from $19.00

'Did you get the hit man Frankie?' mockup

'Did you get the hit man Frankie?'

from $19.00

'When did mum stop just sending us to our room?'

'When did mum stop just sending us to our room?' mockup

'When did mum stop just sending us to our room?'

from $19.00

The farmer says one of his cows are missing, mind if we take a look around

The farmer says one of his cows are missing, mind if we take a look around mockup

The farmer says one of his cows are missing, mind if we take a look around

from $19.00

The big break in the case of the missing French Fries: 'But just to make sure, can you have each of them squawk.'

The big break in the case of the missing French Fries: 'But just to make sure, can you have each of them squawk.' mockup

The big break in the case of the missing French Fries: 'But just to make sure, can you have each of them squawk.'

from $19.00

'Don Francesco, scusi... But while we were burying Luigi, some joggers ran into us... So we had to bury five corpses altogether...'

'Don Francesco, scusi... But while we were burying Luigi, some joggers ran into us... So we had to bury five corpses altogether...' mockup

'Don Francesco, scusi... But while we were burying Luigi, some joggers ran into us... So we had to bury five corpses altogether...'

from $19.00

The Mafia isn't what it used to be... mockup

The Mafia isn't what it used to be...

from $19.00

'Sorry Rocko, you know how it works. Step on a crack, break your mother's back.'

'Sorry Rocko, you know how it works. Step on a crack, break your mother's back.' mockup

'Sorry Rocko, you know how it works. Step on a crack, break your mother's back.'

from $19.00

'The paintings are neolithic, I suspect the Mustaches wee added by a later people.'

'The paintings are neolithic, I suspect the Mustaches wee added by a later people.' mockup

'The paintings are neolithic, I suspect the Mustaches wee added by a later people.'

from $19.00

Recollections of a Retired Butler mockup

Recollections of a Retired Butler

from $19.00

Police are searching for a male between 16 and 25 years, with a silky sheer taupe complexion and a run over his left eye.

Police are searching for a male between 16 and 25 years, with a silky sheer taupe complexion and a run over his left eye. mockup

Police are searching for a male between 16 and 25 years, with a silky sheer taupe complexion and a run over his left eye.

from $19.00

"Whack him. And if you can't whack him, redact him."

"Whack him. And if you can't whack him, redact him." mockup

"Whack him. And if you can't whack him, redact him."

from $19.00

Signs reads 'Do Not Feed the Boids.' mockup

Signs reads 'Do Not Feed the Boids.'

from $19.00

'Before you buy the gun can I ask if you thought about taking your cat to the vets first?'

'Before you buy the gun can I ask if you thought about taking your cat to the vets first?' mockup

'Before you buy the gun can I ask if you thought about taking your cat to the vets first?'

from $19.00

Mafia Mystery Fan Gifts Collection

Mafia Mystery Fan Mugs

Explore our collection of mafia mystery mugs—witty and intriguing designs that are perfect for fans who love a good story with their coffee.

Mafia Mystery Fan Pillows

Discover our mafia mystery pillows—quirky designs that add a mysterious charm to any living space, perfect for fans of intrigue and suspense.

Mafia Mystery Fan Prints

Browse our mafia mystery prints—eye-catching pieces that bring a touch of mystery and wit to any wall, ideal for decorating a crime story aficionado’s home.

Mafia Mystery Fan T-Shirts

Check out our mafia mystery-themed t-shirts—fun and stylish designs that fans will love to wear while solving their own mysteries.