Unexpected Athlete Gifts

Looking for a gift for someone who’s an unexpected athlete? Whether they’re into middle-of-the-road marathons or have a hobby that’s a little offbeat, our creative collection of gifts celebrates their unique spirit. Featuring playful designs that combine humor and heart, these products are perfect for inspiring, amusing, or simply acknowledging the unexpected athlete in your life. Find something memorable that matches their style and passion today.

Unlikely Athlete Accidental Athlete Unconventional Athlete Hidden Athlete Unexpected Artist Unexpected Scientist Unexpected Entertainer Offbeat Athlete Unexpected Surprise Seeker Unexpected Celebrity

All Products Prints T-Shirts Mugs Pillows

'He hates basketball! He hates basketball! He hates basketball!'

'He hates basketball! He hates basketball! He hates basketball!' mockup

'He hates basketball! He hates basketball! He hates basketball!' mockup

'He hates basketball! He hates basketball! He hates basketball!' mockup

'He hates basketball! He hates basketball! He hates basketball!' mockup

'He hates basketball! He hates basketball! He hates basketball!'

from $19.00

"I got super baked in the shire and accidentally recruited these four little weirdos for the most important mission of all time."

"I got super baked in the shire and accidentally recruited these four little weirdos for the most important mission of all time." mockup

"I got super baked in the shire and accidentally recruited these four little weirdos for the most important mission of all time." mockup

"I got super baked in the shire and accidentally recruited these four little weirdos for the most important mission of all time." mockup

"I got super baked in the shire and accidentally recruited these four little weirdos for the most important mission of all time." mockup

"I got super baked in the shire and accidentally recruited these four little weirdos for the most important mission of all time."

from $19.00

'Well, Eddy may look a bit rough, but he's good at heart - last week, he bought stocks from a company which produces cuddly puppy toys in pink ballet dresses!'

'Well, Eddy may look a bit rough, but he's good at heart - last week, he bought stocks from a company which produces cuddly puppy toys in pink ballet dresses!' mockup

'Well, Eddy may look a bit rough, but he's good at heart - last week, he bought stocks from a company which produces cuddly puppy toys in pink ballet dresses!' mockup

'Well, Eddy may look a bit rough, but he's good at heart - last week, he bought stocks from a company which produces cuddly puppy toys in pink ballet dresses!' mockup

'Well, Eddy may look a bit rough, but he's good at heart - last week, he bought stocks from a company which produces cuddly puppy toys in pink ballet dresses!' mockup

'Well, Eddy may look a bit rough, but he's good at heart - last week, he bought stocks from a company which produces cuddly puppy toys in pink ballet dresses!'

from $19.00

"I hope your cast is not itchy, Stacy. I had an itchy cast on my arm once and it itched ALL the time. It felt like crawling ants! Itchy, itchy, itchy..."

"I hope your cast is not itchy, Stacy. I had an itchy cast on my arm once and it itched ALL the time. It felt like crawling ants! Itchy, itchy, itchy..." mockup

"I hope your cast is not itchy, Stacy. I had an itchy cast on my arm once and it itched ALL the time. It felt like crawling ants! Itchy, itchy, itchy..." mockup

"I hope your cast is not itchy, Stacy. I had an itchy cast on my arm once and it itched ALL the time. It felt like crawling ants! Itchy, itchy, itchy..." mockup

"I hope your cast is not itchy, Stacy. I had an itchy cast on my arm once and it itched ALL the time. It felt like crawling ants! Itchy, itchy, itchy..." mockup

"I hope your cast is not itchy, Stacy. I had an itchy cast on my arm once and it itched ALL the time. It felt like crawling ants! Itchy, itchy, itchy..."

from $19.00

Gymnast's Commute

Gymnast's Commute mockup

Gymnast's Commute mockup

Gymnast's Commute mockup

Gymnast's Commute mockup

Gymnast's Commute

from $19.00

'You said you went to night classes to draw birds, and when I asked whether they had clothes on and you said they didn't - you know I didn't expect this!'

'You said you went to night classes to draw birds, and when I asked whether they had clothes on and you said they didn't - you know I didn't expect this!' mockup

'You said you went to night classes to draw birds, and when I asked whether they had clothes on and you said they didn't - you know I didn't expect this!' mockup

'You said you went to night classes to draw birds, and when I asked whether they had clothes on and you said they didn't - you know I didn't expect this!' mockup

'You said you went to night classes to draw birds, and when I asked whether they had clothes on and you said they didn't - you know I didn't expect this!' mockup

'You said you went to night classes to draw birds, and when I asked whether they had clothes on and you said they didn't - you know I didn't expect this!'

from $19.00

'There was a time when I considered making myself available for the NBA draft. But one day I realized, hey - I'm a slug! I don't have an athletic bone in my body!'

'There was a time when I considered making myself available for the NBA draft. But one day I realized, hey - I'm a slug! I don't have an athletic bone in my body!' mockup

'There was a time when I considered making myself available for the NBA draft. But one day I realized, hey - I'm a slug! I don't have an athletic bone in my body!' mockup

'There was a time when I considered making myself available for the NBA draft. But one day I realized, hey - I'm a slug! I don't have an athletic bone in my body!' mockup

'There was a time when I considered making myself available for the NBA draft. But one day I realized, hey - I'm a slug! I don't have an athletic bone in my body!' mockup

'There was a time when I considered making myself available for the NBA draft. But one day I realized, hey - I'm a slug! I don't have an athletic bone in my body!'

from $19.00

'All I've ever wanted to do is dance!'

'All I've ever wanted to do is dance!' mockup

'All I've ever wanted to do is dance!' mockup

'All I've ever wanted to do is dance!' mockup

'All I've ever wanted to do is dance!' mockup

'All I've ever wanted to do is dance!'

from $19.00

Man reading letter, 'You may already be a winner' about to step on rake.

Man reading letter, 'You may already be a winner' about to step on rake. mockup

Man reading letter, 'You may already be a winner' about to step on rake. mockup

Man reading letter, 'You may already be a winner' about to step on rake. mockup

Man reading letter, 'You may already be a winner' about to step on rake. mockup

Man reading letter, 'You may already be a winner' about to step on rake.

from $19.00

Magician conjures up a crocodile and is chased by it

Magician conjures up a crocodile and is chased by it mockup

Magician conjures up a crocodile and is chased by it mockup

Magician conjures up a crocodile and is chased by it mockup

Magician conjures up a crocodile and is chased by it mockup

Magician conjures up a crocodile and is chased by it

from $19.00

Bowled out. mockup

Bowled out. mockup

Bowled out. mockup

Bowled out. mockup

Bowled out.

from $19.00

Monk Parrot. mockup

Monk Parrot. mockup

Monk Parrot. mockup

Monk Parrot. mockup

Monk Parrot.

from $19.00

Javelin

from $19.00

'He doesn't like to catch anything - He just fishes for the exercise!'

'He doesn't like to catch anything - He just fishes for the exercise!' mockup

'He doesn't like to catch anything - He just fishes for the exercise!' mockup

'He doesn't like to catch anything - He just fishes for the exercise!' mockup

'He doesn't like to catch anything - He just fishes for the exercise!' mockup

'He doesn't like to catch anything - He just fishes for the exercise!'

from $19.00

'What do you mean there's no specific rule that forbids a center fielder from doing that?'

'What do you mean there's no specific rule that forbids a center fielder from doing that?' mockup

'What do you mean there's no specific rule that forbids a center fielder from doing that?' mockup

'What do you mean there's no specific rule that forbids a center fielder from doing that?' mockup

'What do you mean there's no specific rule that forbids a center fielder from doing that?' mockup

'What do you mean there's no specific rule that forbids a center fielder from doing that?'

from $19.00

Street Football

Street Football mockup

Street Football mockup

Street Football mockup

Street Football mockup

Street Football

from $19.00

Colin was determined not to go thirsty on the fun run,,,

Colin was determined not to go thirsty on the fun run,,, mockup

Colin was determined not to go thirsty on the fun run,,, mockup

Colin was determined not to go thirsty on the fun run,,, mockup

Colin was determined not to go thirsty on the fun run,,, mockup

Colin was determined not to go thirsty on the fun run,,,

from $19.00

'The trouble with facing reality is you never know from which direction it's coming from.'

'The trouble with facing reality is you never know from which direction it's coming from.' mockup

'The trouble with facing reality is you never know from which direction it's coming from.' mockup

'The trouble with facing reality is you never know from which direction it's coming from.' mockup

'The trouble with facing reality is you never know from which direction it's coming from.' mockup

'The trouble with facing reality is you never know from which direction it's coming from.'

from $19.00

'I love these computerized running shoes that do the running without you.'

'I love these computerized running shoes that do the running without you.' mockup

'I love these computerized running shoes that do the running without you.' mockup

'I love these computerized running shoes that do the running without you.' mockup

'I love these computerized running shoes that do the running without you.' mockup

'I love these computerized running shoes that do the running without you.'

from $19.00

Life is full of surprises.

Life is full of surprises. mockup

Life is full of surprises. mockup

Life is full of surprises. mockup

Life is full of surprises. mockup

Life is full of surprises.

from $19.00

Too small to play forward. Too slow to play guard.

Too small to play forward. Too slow to play guard. mockup

Too small to play forward. Too slow to play guard. mockup

Too small to play forward. Too slow to play guard. mockup

Too small to play forward. Too slow to play guard. mockup

Too small to play forward. Too slow to play guard.

from $19.00

"Pretty nasty slice."

"Pretty nasty slice." mockup

"Pretty nasty slice." mockup

"Pretty nasty slice." mockup

"Pretty nasty slice." mockup

"Pretty nasty slice."

from $19.00

A skier who has hit a solitary tree

A skier who has hit a solitary tree mockup

A skier who has hit a solitary tree mockup

A skier who has hit a solitary tree mockup

A skier who has hit a solitary tree mockup

A skier who has hit a solitary tree

from $19.00

"The video of you giving that big bloke a piece of your mind has gone viral!"

"The video of you giving that big bloke a piece of your mind has gone viral!" mockup

"The video of you giving that big bloke a piece of your mind has gone viral!" mockup

"The video of you giving that big bloke a piece of your mind has gone viral!" mockup

"The video of you giving that big bloke a piece of your mind has gone viral!" mockup

"The video of you giving that big bloke a piece of your mind has gone viral!"

from $19.00

"I dragged a man out of a burning building. Un"fortunately, it was a fireman...

"I dragged a man out of a burning building. Un"fortunately, it was a fireman... mockup

"I dragged a man out of a burning building. Un"fortunately, it was a fireman... mockup

"I dragged a man out of a burning building. Un"fortunately, it was a fireman... mockup

"I dragged a man out of a burning building. Un"fortunately, it was a fireman... mockup

"I dragged a man out of a burning building. Un"fortunately, it was a fireman...

from $19.00

'I tripped over one of those 'Caution Slippery Floor' signs.'

'I tripped over one of those 'Caution Slippery Floor' signs.' mockup

'I tripped over one of those 'Caution Slippery Floor' signs.' mockup

'I tripped over one of those 'Caution Slippery Floor' signs.' mockup

'I tripped over one of those 'Caution Slippery Floor' signs.' mockup

'I tripped over one of those 'Caution Slippery Floor' signs.'

from $19.00

"The control group has taken control."

"The control group has taken control." mockup

"The control group has taken control." mockup

"The control group has taken control." mockup

"The control group has taken control." mockup

"The control group has taken control."

from $19.00

Tramp Advertising: Your Ad Here.

Tramp Advertising: Your Ad Here. mockup

Tramp Advertising: Your Ad Here. mockup

Tramp Advertising: Your Ad Here. mockup

Tramp Advertising: Your Ad Here. mockup

Tramp Advertising: Your Ad Here.

from $19.00

'Do you know what I feel like Doris? I feel like kickin' some ass.'

'Do you know what I feel like Doris? I feel like kickin' some ass.' mockup

'Do you know what I feel like Doris? I feel like kickin' some ass.' mockup

'Do you know what I feel like Doris? I feel like kickin' some ass.' mockup

'Do you know what I feel like Doris? I feel like kickin' some ass.' mockup

'Do you know what I feel like Doris? I feel like kickin' some ass.'

from $19.00

Unexpected Athlete Gifts Collection

Unexpected Athlete Mugs

Explore our collection of mugs designed for the unexpected athlete—perfect for morning motivation or a humorous coffee break.

Unexpected Athlete Pillows

Discover cozy pillows that showcase the unexpected athlete’s spirit with humor and charm—perfect for any sports lover’s home.

Unexpected Athlete Prints

Browse our vibrant prints to inspire or amuse the unexpected athlete with art that celebrates their unique sports adventures.

Unexpected Athlete T-Shirts

Check out our fun and inspiring t-shirts for athletes who love to stand out and celebrate their unique sports journey.