True Crime Skeptic Gifts

Searching for the ideal gift for a true crime skeptic? Our curated collection offers humorous and thoughtful products that nod to their love of questioning narratives and seeking the truth. From witty mugs to stylish t-shirts, find a unique gift that aligns with their skeptical spirit and passion for justice. These items are perfect for anyone who enjoys a clever take on crime stories and values critical thinking.

All Products Prints T-Shirts Mugs Pillows

Meet John Henderson. - The only journalist NOT to have interviewed serial killers in prison...

Meet John Henderson. - The only journalist NOT to have interviewed serial killers in prison... mockup

Meet John Henderson. - The only journalist NOT to have interviewed serial killers in prison...

from $19.00

'Am I being too suspicious or do you think it's possible that they're crooked?'

'Am I being too suspicious or do you think it's possible that they're crooked?' mockup

'Am I being too suspicious or do you think it's possible that they're crooked?'

from $19.00

"Talk, Wallace - where'd you hide the loot?"

"Talk, Wallace - where'd you hide the loot?" mockup

"Talk, Wallace - where'd you hide the loot?"

from $19.00

'I'm sure that the autopsy will confirm it was a suicide.'

'I'm sure that the autopsy will confirm it was a suicide.' mockup

'I'm sure that the autopsy will confirm it was a suicide.'

from $19.00

OK! I promise that the questions will be easy!

OK! I promise that the questions will be easy! mockup

OK! I promise that the questions will be easy!

from $19.00

"True crime meets reality TV"

from $19.00

"Number 2. Step forward please."

from $19.00

"Since he's been a plagiarist, committed perjury and runs a Ponzi scheme, trust can be an issue."

"Since he's been a plagiarist, committed perjury and runs a Ponzi scheme, trust can be an issue." mockup

"Since he's been a plagiarist, committed perjury and runs a Ponzi scheme, trust can be an issue."

from $19.00

"I worked hard, I played hard and I embezzled hard."

"I worked hard, I played hard and I embezzled hard." mockup

"I worked hard, I played hard and I embezzled hard."

from $19.00

A Young Boy Talking To An Old Gentleman.

A Young Boy Talking To An Old Gentleman. mockup

A Young Boy Talking To An Old Gentleman.

from $19.00

Crime in bookshop

from $19.00

"Why not stay with your mother and me? The Feds will never find you here."

"Why not stay with your mother and me? The Feds will never find you here." mockup

"Why not stay with your mother and me? The Feds will never find you here."

from $19.00

Madoff and devil.

from $19.00

'It's heartbreaking to see Reynolds in trouble for fraud again, but I always look forward to his rooftop chases.'

'It's heartbreaking to see Reynolds in trouble for fraud again, but I always look forward to his rooftop chases.' mockup

'It's heartbreaking to see Reynolds in trouble for fraud again, but I always look forward to his rooftop chases.'

from $19.00

Book Thief in True Crime Department mockup

Book Thief in True Crime Department

from $19.00

'Looks like the victim was trying to tell us something,'

'Looks like the victim was trying to tell us something,' mockup

'Looks like the victim was trying to tell us something,'

from $19.00

"I'm starting to prefer the ones who don't believe in me."

"I'm starting to prefer the ones who don't believe in me." mockup

"I'm starting to prefer the ones who don't believe in me."

from $19.00

'Tonight's special presentation, 'The Myth of the Mafia,' was made possible by a grant from the Gambino family.'

'Tonight's special presentation, 'The Myth of the Mafia,' was made possible by a grant from the Gambino family.' mockup

'Tonight's special presentation, 'The Myth of the Mafia,' was made possible by a grant from the Gambino family.'

from $19.00

"Don't worry, honey. This is just for our murder podcast."

"Don't worry, honey. This is just for our murder podcast." mockup

"Don't worry, honey. This is just for our murder podcast."

from $19.00

"The sweet smell of the leaves and the rain make fall such a refreshing time!"

"The sweet smell of the leaves and the rain make fall such a refreshing time!" mockup

"The sweet smell of the leaves and the rain make fall such a refreshing time!"

from $19.00

Arrest of La Tuta

from $19.00

'I've written a poem describing my feelings on discovering the body, Inspector...'

'I've written a poem describing my feelings on discovering the body, Inspector...' mockup

'I've written a poem describing my feelings on discovering the body, Inspector...'

from $19.00

"I believe this is a case for Sherlock Holmes..."

"I believe this is a case for Sherlock Holmes..." mockup

"I believe this is a case for Sherlock Holmes..."

from $19.00

"It was me who did it!"

from $19.00

'...and as a consequence, you lot all redundant. I'm not making it up.'

'...and as a consequence, you lot all redundant. I'm not making it up.' mockup

'...and as a consequence, you lot all redundant. I'm not making it up.'

from $19.00

"Another clear case of COVID19."

from $19.00

'So far we don't have any suspects.' mockup

'So far we don't have any suspects.'

from $19.00

"3:14 p.m. Suspect drives to lakeside resort. Rents rowboat under false name. Tosses evidence into... wait, how do I tell anyone?" Topper: Undercover police dog

"3:14 p.m. Suspect drives to lakeside resort. Rents rowboat under false name. Tosses evidence into... wait, how do I tell anyone?" Topper: Undercover police dog

from $19.00

"Convicts selling novels from prison? At least that could never happen here, eh Jones?"

"Convicts selling novels from prison? At least that could never happen here, eh Jones?" mockup

"Convicts selling novels from prison? At least that could never happen here, eh Jones?"

from $19.00

"Do you swear you haven't embroidered the truth in your testimony today?"

"Do you swear you haven't embroidered the truth in your testimony today?" mockup

"Do you swear you haven't embroidered the truth in your testimony today?"

from $19.00

'A free plastic toy, cornflakes scattered around the victim... Yep, it looks like our cereal killer alright!'

'A free plastic toy, cornflakes scattered around the victim... Yep, it looks like our cereal killer alright!' mockup

'A free plastic toy, cornflakes scattered around the victim... Yep, it looks like our cereal killer alright!'

from $19.00

True Crime Skeptic Gifts Collection

True Crime Skeptic Mugs

Explore our range of mugs that cater to true crime skeptics. Find a witty or insightful design perfect for coffee, tea, or their favorite hot beverage.

True Crime Skeptic Pillows

Check out pillows that feature humorous and skeptical quotes, adding personality and comfort to their living space.

True Crime Skeptic Prints

Discover prints that celebrate curiosity and skepticism, perfect for adorning walls with wit and insight.

True Crime Skeptic T-Shirts

Browse our selection of T-shirts designed for true crime skeptics. Playful and clever, these shirts are great for expressing their unique perspective.