Creepy Story Collector Gifts

If you know someone who loves collecting creepy stories, find the perfect quirky gifts that capture their dark curiosity. Our curated selection of fun and slightly eerie products—from mugs to prints—are ideal for those who thrive on spooky narratives and haunting tales. Whether they enjoy sharing chilling stories or just love creepy themes, our creative gifts bring their fascination to life with humor and style.

All Products Prints T-Shirts Mugs Pillows

"Well, we found out what's been clogging your chimney since last December, Miss Emmy."

"Well, we found out what's been clogging your chimney since last December, Miss Emmy." mockup

"Well, we found out what's been clogging your chimney since last December, Miss Emmy."

from $19.00

"It's such a beautiful day. Why don't we go out and get someone to eat?"

"It's such a beautiful day. Why don't we go out and get someone to eat?" mockup

"It's such a beautiful day. Why don't we go out and get someone to eat?"

from $19.00

'I'm the ghost of Christmas future. I'm hammered, can we do this later...?'

'I'm the ghost of Christmas future. I'm hammered, can we do this later...?' mockup

'I'm the ghost of Christmas future. I'm hammered, can we do this later...?'

from $19.00

"Do you live nearby by any chance? I hate to eat in public."

"Do you live nearby by any chance? I hate to eat in public." mockup

"Do you live nearby by any chance? I hate to eat in public."

from $19.00

Monster Baseball

from $19.00

'That's my weird Uncle Benny. He claims that he was abducted by aliens in white lab coats.'

'That's my weird Uncle Benny. He claims that he was abducted by aliens in white lab coats.' mockup

'That's my weird Uncle Benny. He claims that he was abducted by aliens in white lab coats.'

from $19.00

"No, I don't think you 'new break shoes', I think you need new break feet. You are supposed to depress the brake pedal you know."

"No, I don't think you 'new break shoes', I think you need new break feet. You are supposed to depress the brake pedal you know." mockup

"No, I don't think you 'new break shoes', I think you need new break feet. You are supposed to depress the brake pedal you know."

from $19.00

'He's a blight on the whole neighbourhood.'

'He's a blight on the whole neighbourhood.' mockup

'He's a blight on the whole neighbourhood.'

from $19.00

Who's Dead

from $19.00

''Masterpiece Theater' will not be seen tonight, so that we may bring you 'Slushpile Showplace'....'

''Masterpiece Theater' will not be seen tonight, so that we may bring you 'Slushpile Showplace'....' mockup

''Masterpiece Theater' will not be seen tonight, so that we may bring you 'Slushpile Showplace'....'

from $19.00

"I've seen a lot in my time, Ted, but it was always from the cheap seats."

"I've seen a lot in my time, Ted, but it was always from the cheap seats." mockup

"I've seen a lot in my time, Ted, but it was always from the cheap seats."

from $19.00

Master Humphrey's visionary friends mockup

Master Humphrey's visionary friends

from $19.00

'-but the fire's on the GROUND floor!' mockup

'-but the fire's on the GROUND floor!'

from $19.00

"You're right - organs do look more festive in these cute mason jars."

"You're right - organs do look more festive in these cute mason jars." mockup

"You're right - organs do look more festive in these cute mason jars."

from $19.00

A headless man puts up a poster for his lost head.

A headless man puts up a poster for his lost head. mockup

A headless man puts up a poster for his lost head.

from $19.00

"There, there, dear. It's perfectly normal for a new bride on her wedding night to shit like a goose on her husband."

"There, there, dear. It's perfectly normal for a new bride on her wedding night to shit like a goose on her husband." mockup

"There, there, dear. It's perfectly normal for a new bride on her wedding night to shit like a goose on her husband."

from $19.00

Excess Baggage: As soon as you pick a vacation destination, people who have never been there start to tell you horror stories about the place.

Excess Baggage: As soon as you pick a vacation destination, people who have never been there start to tell you horror stories about the place. mockup

Excess Baggage: As soon as you pick a vacation destination, people who have never been there start to tell you horror stories about the place.

from $19.00

A frog catches an insect truck.

from $19.00

'Yes, he did turn into a price, but there were complications.'

'Yes, he did turn into a price, but there were complications.' mockup

'Yes, he did turn into a price, but there were complications.'

from $19.00

A Ghost

from $19.00

"Grandpa! You have to let me put those under my pillow!"

"Grandpa! You have to let me put those under my pillow!" mockup

"Grandpa! You have to let me put those under my pillow!"

from $19.00

'You've become a right pain in the neck.'

'You've become a right pain in the neck.' mockup

'You've become a right pain in the neck.'

from $19.00

Floods leave man and ghost stranded. mockup

Floods leave man and ghost stranded.

from $19.00

Frankenstein Collectibles: Buyer Beware mockup

Frankenstein Collectibles: Buyer Beware

from $19.00

Sea Angel

from $19.00

Home Sweet Home

from $19.00

'I've known you a long time and it's time I told you the truth, I'm not really a person, I'm just a suit full of chickens..'

'I've known you a long time and it's time I told you the truth, I'm not really a person, I'm just a suit full of chickens..' mockup

'I've known you a long time and it's time I told you the truth, I'm not really a person, I'm just a suit full of chickens..'

from $19.00

Two witches argue after crashing into each other

Two witches argue after crashing into each other mockup

Two witches argue after crashing into each other

from $19.00

Staff picks

from $19.00

"Gentlemen, this is Mr. Griscom, Super Films' new horror expert."

"Gentlemen, this is Mr. Griscom, Super Films' new horror expert." mockup

"Gentlemen, this is Mr. Griscom, Super Films' new horror expert."

from $19.00

Homeless man's sign: 'Will sell book & movie rights to the story of my downfall for a cool million.'

Homeless man's sign: 'Will sell book & movie rights to the story of my downfall for a cool million.' mockup

Homeless man's sign: 'Will sell book & movie rights to the story of my downfall for a cool million.'

from $19.00

Prompts on the Antiques Roadshow. mockup

Prompts on the Antiques Roadshow.

from $19.00

Excess Baggage: As soon as you pick a vacation destination, people who have never been there start to tell you horror stories about the place.

from $19.00

Creepy Story Collector Gifts Collection

Creepy Story Collector Mugs

Explore our collection of creepy story-themed mugs—perfect for collectors who enjoy a darkly delightful brew each morning.

Creepy Story Collector Pillows

Find pillows with creepy tales-inspired graphics—ideal for adding mysterious charm to any room or reading nook.

Creepy Story Collector Prints

Browse our creepy story-themed prints, perfect for framing and celebrating their love for spine-chilling narratives.

Creepy Story Collector T-Shirts

Discover t-shirts that speak to creepy story lovers—fun, spooky designs that make a bold statement or a subtle nod to their passions.